|Ahead of print publication
Low ambient temperature correlates with the severity of dry eye symptoms
Wei-Ting Ho1, Chiung-Yi Chiu2, Shu-Wen Chang3
1 Department of Ophthalmology, Far Eastern Memorial Hospital, New Taipei City; School of Medicine, National Yang Ming Chiao Tung University, Hsinchu, Taiwan
2 Department of Ophthalmology, Far Eastern Memorial Hospital, New Taipei City, Taiwan
3 Department of Ophthalmology, Far Eastern Memorial Hospital, New Taipei City; Department of Ophthalmology, National Taiwan University Hospital, Taipei, Taiwan
|Date of Submission||11-Apr-2021|
|Date of Acceptance||28-May-2021|
|Date of Web Publication||28-Aug-2021|
No. 21, Sec. 2, Nanya S. Rd., Banciao Dist., New Taipei City 220
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
PURPOSE: The symptoms of dry eye disease (DED) are influenced by environmental factors, but the effect of ambient temperature is less certain. Our purpose was to investigate the relationship between the severity of DED symptoms and the ambient temperature.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: This retrospective study reviewed the symptom scores, including ocular surface disease index (OSDI) and standardized patient evaluation of eye dryness (SPEED), as well as tear film parameters of first-time DED patients between June 2018 and June 2019. The contribution of tear film parameters and environmental factors, including ambient temperature, humidity, wind speed, and the concentration of air pollutants, to the severity of dry eye symptoms was evaluated by univariate and multivariate linear regression analyses.
RESULTS: There were 351 patients included aged 52.8 ± 13.6 years, and 257 (73.2%) were female. The average tear film break-up time, Schirmer test value, and lipid layer thickness were 2.6 ± 0.7 s, 5.5 ± 4.3 mm, and 64.1 ± 6.0 μm, respectively. The average OSDI and SPEED were 41.8 ± 19.8 and 12.1 ± 5.1, respectively. In winter, the patients reported higher OSDI and SPEED. Both scores were significantly correlated with low ambient temperature. Regression analysis showed that low ambient temperature and Schirmer test value contributed to higher OSDI, while low ambient temperature and younger age contributed to higher SPEED.
CONCLUSION: Low ambient temperature plays a significant role in DED symptom severity.
Keywords: Dry eye disease, ocular surface disease index, standardized patient evaluation of eye dryness, temperature
| Introduction|| |
Dry eye disease (DED) is a common ocular disease in the modern world, with a prevalence of 5%–50%. It is characterized with unstable tear film, a hallmark sign of DED, which leads to ocular surface inflammation and subsequent injury. The resulting symptoms may not only lead to ocular discomfort and visual disturbance but also impact patients' quality of life.
Several risk factors of DED have been identified, such as aging, female sex, Asian race, Meibomian gland More Details dysfunction, and Sjögren syndrome. In addition to these patient-specific risk factors, environmental factors also play a significant role in contributing to DED prevalence and its severity. For example, low relative humidity has been shown to increase tear evaporation and ocular discomfort. Wind exposure also increases dry eye prevalence. Furthermore, several air pollutants, including PM2.5 and ozone, are associated with DED and ocular surface inflammation.,
Among the environmental factors, the role of ambient temperature is less certain. A previous study found that the prevalence of DED is higher in winter and spring. However, other studies found that temperature is positively correlated with DED incidence, and higher temperature is associated with increased tear evaporation rate., Concerning the complex nature of DED and high inconsistency between signs and symptoms, we analyzed the symptoms quantitated by ocular surface disease index (OSDI) and standard patient evaluation of eye dryness (SPEED) questionnaires and correlated the scores with environmental factors, including meteorological parameters. This result may shed light on the effect of ambient temperature on DED symptoms.
| Materials and Methods|| |
This retrospective study adhered to the tenets of the Declaration of Helsinki and was approved by the Research Ethics Review Committee of the Far Eastern Memorial Hospital, New Taipei City, Taiwan. Waiver of informed consent was also approved by the Committee, as this study was based on the retrospective review of the clinical data (approval number: 107163-E). Data of first-time DED patients from June 2018 to June 2019 were included for analysis. To evaluate the influence of environmental factors at different time points on DED symptoms, only patients living in four adjacent districts to Far Eastern Memorial Hospital (Banqiao, Tucheng, Xinzhuang, and Shulin Districts, New Taipei City, Taiwan) were included to avoid confounding by geographical factors. The diagnosis of DED was based on the definition by the Asia Dry Eye Society if the patients presented with both dry eye symptoms and unstable tear film. Dry eye symptoms were assessed by OSDI and those with OSDI ≧ 13 were considered to have DED symptoms. Tear film stability was assessed by tear film break-up time (TBUT), and the cutoff value was ≤ 5 s for DED diagnosis. Exclusion criteria included (1) history of ocular surgery, ocular trauma, or ocular infection within 3 months; (2) active use of topical or systemic medications that may interfere with tear film stability, including artificial tears, antiglaucoma agents, anthistamines, and antipsychotics; (3) contact lens wearing within 1 week; (4) autoimmune diseases such as Sicca syndrome, systemic lupus erythematosus, rheumatoid arthritis, and Steven–Johnson syndrome.
The symptoms of DED patients were assessed by OSDI as aforementioned. SPEED questionnaire was also used to evaluate symptom severity, which is better correlated with DED caused by meibomian gland dysfunction. All patients completed OSDI and SPEED questionnaires were subjected to routine DED evaluation as follows. TBUT was evaluated by instilling 2 μl of 0.5% fluorescein into the lower fornix, and the interval between the last blink and the first TBUT was recorded. Lipid layer thickness (LLT) and meibomian gland morphology were evaluated using the LipiView II interferometer (TearScience Inc., Morrisville, NC, USA). The amount of expressible meibomian glands (MGE) was recorded after applying the standardized diagnostic expression instrument (TearScience Inc., Morrisville, NC, USA) on the lid margin. Aqueous tear secretion was evaluated using the Schirmer test II with topical anesthetics measured at 5 min using a standard 35 mm × 5 mm tear test strip (EagleVision, Katena Products, USA). Only the data from the right eye were included for statistical analysis.
To evaluate the correlation between the severity of DED symptoms and environmental factors, daily mean temperature, relative humidity, and wind speed from monitor stations of the aforementioned districts were acquired from the database of Central Weather Bureau, Taiwan (www.cwb.gov.tw). The daily average parameters from the four districts were used to correlate with each patient's symptoms on the visit date. To further explore the correlation between dry eye symptoms and air pollutants, the daily average concentration of air pollutants, including PM10, PM2.5, SO2, O3, CO, CH4, NO, NO2, total hydrocarbon (THC), nonmethane hydrocarbon, and the air quality index, was collected from the database of Environmental Protection Administration, Executive Yuan, Taiwan (www.epa.gov.tw).
Statistical analysis was performed using SPSS for Windows (version 19.0, SPSS Inc., Chicago, Illinois, USA). Analysis of variance (ANOVA) with Bonferroni post hoc test was used to test the difference between groups. Pearson's correlation analysis and linear regression analysis were performed to explore the correlation between the severity of dry eye symptoms and environmental factors. Results were considered statistically significant if P < 0.05.
| Results|| |
During the study period, we collected data from 351 patients. The mean age was 52.8 ± 13.6 years, and the percentage of female was 73.2% [Table 1]. The mean TBUT was 2.6 ± 0.7 s, indicating unstable tear film in these patients. Mean OSDI and SPEED scores of the whole study group were 41.8 ± 19.8 and 12.1 ± 5.1, respectively. The mean OSDI of female and male was 42.74 ± 19.80 and 39.08 ± 19.40 (P = 0.12), while the mean SPEED scores were 12.07 ± 4.90 and 12.11 ± 5.71 (P = 0.94), respectively. Other tear film characteristics are summarized in [Table 1].
To evaluate the potential influence of environmental factors on the severity of DED symptoms, we arbitrarily divided the patients into four groups according to the seasons of visit. First-time DED patients visiting dry eye clinic in winter reported significantly higher OSDI and SPEED scores compared with those in other seasons, especially in summer [Figure 1]a and [Figure 1]b. When plotting the symptom severity against the temperature, there was a trend of increasing OSDI or SPEED score with decreasing ambient temperature [Figure 1]c and [Figure 1]d. Linear correlation analysis also showed that both OSDI and SPEED scores were negatively correlated with the ambient temperature [Figure 2]a and [Figure 2]b. These results imply that DED symptoms were worse in winter, and low ambient temperature may be one of the contributing factors.
|Figure 1: Seasonal change of dry eye disease symptoms. (a and b) Seasonal change of OSDI and SPEED scores from June 2018 to June 2019. Spring: March to May; summer: June to August; fall: September to November; winter: December to February. *P < 0.05, ***P < 0.001 by ANOVA with Bonferroni post hoc test. (c and d) Change in OSDI and SPEED scores relative to ambient temperature. Average symptom scores versus ambient temperature per week were plotted for curve smoothing.|
Click here to view
|Figure 2: Low ambient temperature is associated with higher OSDI and SPEED scores. (a and b) Scatter plots of OSDI and SPEED scores of each patient versus ambient temperature of the visiting date.|
Click here to view
In addition to low ambient temperature, relative humidity and wind speed also influence the prevalence, signs, and symptoms of DED. Furthermore, air quality is usually deteriorated during winter months in Taiwan. Previous studies also showed that air pollutants were associated with DED and ocular surface inflammation., Therefore, aggravated DED symptoms may be, in fact, caused by other meteorological factors and air pollution in winter, instead of low ambient temperature. To explore the correlation between symptom severity and air pollution as well as other meteorological factors, we first performed univariate linear regression analysis and identified Schirmer value, temperature, CO, NO2, THC, and CH4 to be correlated with OSDI [Table 2]. Further, multivariate regression analysis was performed by selecting Schirmer value, temperature, and one of the air pollutants as variables due to high collinearity among the air pollutants [Table 3]. Although Schirmer value and temperature remained negatively correlated with OSDI, the effect of air pollutants became insignificant after adjusting the confounding effect [Table 4]. As for SPEED score, it was negatively correlated with age and temperature and was positively correlated with PM2.5, CO, NO2, THC, and CH4 by univariate analysis [Table 5]. Multivariate analysis showed that age and temperature remained negatively correlated with SPEED, while the effect of other air pollutants became insignificant [Table 6]. Both OSDI and SPEED scores were not affected by the indicators of tear film stability, including TBUT, LLT, and MGE [Table 2] and [Table 5].
|Table 2: Univariate linear regression analysis between OSDI and the variables|
Click here to view
|Table 4: Multivariate linear regression analysis between OSDI and the variables|
Click here to view
|Table 5: Univariate linear regression analysis between SPEED and the variables|
Click here to view
|Table 6: Multivariate linear regression analysis between SPEED and the variables|
Click here to view
| Discussion|| |
Environmental factors consistently associated with DED include pollution, low humidity, and sick building syndrome according to the DEWS II report. In this study, we found that the mean OSDI and SPEED scores were higher in winter, and both scores were significantly correlated with low ambient temperature. Multivariate analysis showed that OSDI was negatively correlated with Schirmer value and temperature, while SPEED score was negatively correlated with age and temperature. Compared with OSDI, SPEED score is considered to be better correlated with DED caused by meibomian gland dysfunction. In our previous study, we also found that SPEED score is higher in younger age group, while the difference in OSDI scores among age groups was borderline. Therefore, different questionnaires may better reflect symptom severity under certain patient demographics. Among all the variables analyzed in this study, only ambient temperature was negatively correlated with both OSDI and SPEED. This finding convincingly suggests that low ambient temperature correlates with DED symptoms.
Intriguingly, a previous study showed that temperature is positively correlated with DED incidence in Taiwan. However, the effect size is relatively small (odds ratio = 1.005–1.016), and the data were obtained from the cohort database of the National Health Insurance of Taiwan, which identifies DED patients by disease coding from 2004 to 2013. During that time, the diagnosis of DED was mostly made based on the Schirmer test, which is known for variable test result and suboptimal ability to discriminate between normal and DED subjects. The authors also found that every 10% increment of relative humidity was related to approximately 6.7% reduction in DED occurrence, suggesting that moisture in the air might have mitigated the DED symptoms. In contrast, the diagnosis of DED in this study was based on the criteria by the Asia Dry Eye Society, and the severity of symptoms was assessed by OSDI and SPEED questionnaire. Only patients presented with DED symptoms (OSDI average 41.8 ± 19.8) and unstable tear film (TBUT average 2.6 ± 0.7 s) were included. Since short TBUT dry eye is the predominant manifestation of DED, our approach offers better insight into the role of different environmental factors contributing to the symptom severity among DED patients.
In previous studies, air pollution is associated with DED signs, symptoms, and incidence.,, In Taiwan, air pollution is often worse during winter monsoon due to long-range transport of air pollutants from East Asia., Despite that the relative humidity is relatively stable, wind speed is usually higher in winter season in Taiwan, leading us to hypothesize that higher OSDI and SPEED scores were in fact caused by these environmental or meteorological factors, instead of low ambient temperature. However, among these factors, only temperature remained negatively correlated with DED symptom scores after multivariate regression analysis. A previous study showed that low ambient temperature may cause plugging or constriction of the meibomian gland orifice, thereby decreasing lipid layer thickness and compromising the tear film stability. Nevertheless, regression analysis in our study failed to identify the effect of TBUT, LLT, and MGE on OSDI or SPEED scores. These seemingly contradictory observations may result from the cutoff value of TBUT (≦5 s) in our study, thereby selecting the patients with unstable tear film and obscuring the overall effect of tear film stability on DED symptoms.
Another possibility that low ambient temperature contributes to DED symptoms may be through stimulating the corneal nerve and eliciting ocular discomfort. Corneal sensory nerves can be generally classified as polymodal nociceptor, cold thermoceptor, and mechano-nociceptor neurons. Among these, cold thermoceptor neurons, regarded as the regulator of basal tear secretion due to its response to hyperosmolarity, can also be triggered by cooling, which induces unpleasant sensations in humans., Intriguingly, the prevalence of DED is around 30% in Taiwan compared with 20%–30% in Japan, South Korea, and Shandong province of China, where the latitude is higher and the temperature in winter is usually colder.,,, This discrepancy may be explained by different life styles among countries. For example, air conditioners or heaters are less used in winter in Taiwan compared with high-altitude countries. In Taiwan, motorcycles are the most common means of transportation, thereby exposing the riders to environmental factors more. All these aspects may aggravate DED symptoms in our patients. Further studies may be performed to evaluate the influence of life style in the susceptibility of DED symptoms caused by low ambient temperature.
One confounding factor that could have been encountered is that OSDI questionnaire assesses dry eye symptoms in the past week of the patient's life. However, we correlated this OSDI with the environmental parameters on the day of examination. The effects could thus be nullified and underestimated. In addition, OSDI scores of 13–22, 23–32, >33 represent mild, moderate, and severe DED, respectively. The mean OSDI of our patients was 41.8 ± 19.8, indicating that the symptom severity was relatively high in our patients. Therefore, the symptom scores of some patients may be near plateau, leading to underestimation of the effect of environmental factors on DED symptoms.
There are some limitations in our study. Our case number was only 351, which is relatively small compared with other studies. Furthermore, 73.2% of the patients included in 1-year time span were female, raising the concern that the conclusion may only be applied to female group. However, the sex distribution in our study reflected the fact that female is a dominant risk factor of DED prevalence. Although we found marginally higher OSDI in female patients (42.74 ± 19.80 in female vs. 39.08 ± 19.40 in male), the difference was not statistically significant by univariate regression analysis (P = 0.12), indicating that the contribution of sex to symptom severity was less obvious. To exclude confounding by geographical factors, we only enrolled patients living in four adjacent districts in New Taipei City, where the air pollution in winter is generally mild compared with southern part of Taiwan. This may explain that air pollutants have no obvious effect in DED symptom severity in our multivariate regression models. The localized nature of our findings may also hinder the extrapolation to other regions in the world, since the average temperature is variable. Although further studies conducted in areas with different extents of air pollution and average ambient temperature may be warranted, our findings still have merit that local meteorological data are crucial in determining the severity of DED symptoms of nearby patients. Finally, to better understand the causal relationship between DED symptoms and environmental factors, a longitudinal cohort study is more convincing. However, most DED patients come to hospital for treatment to relieve symptoms and signs in the real world. Consequently, patients usually receive treatment soon after diagnosis that may mask symptom severity under different environmental conditions. In this study, we only included the data of DED patients only at the time of their first visit to our dry eye clinic. Compared with longitudinal approach, our results still have merits to depict the symptom severity of first-time DED patients in different seasons in the real world.
| Conclusion|| |
Our study demonstrated that low ambient temperature is correlated with OSDI and SPEED scores. This finding may shed light on the environment effect on DED symptoms.
Financial support and sponsorship
Conflicts of interest
The authors declare that there are no conflicts of interests of this paper.
| References|| |
Stapleton F, Alves M, Bunya VY, Jalbert I, Lekhanont K, Malet F, et al
. TFOS DEWS II epidemiology report. Ocul Surf 2017;15:334-65.
Tsubota K, Yokoi N, Shimazaki J, Watanabe H, Dogru M, Yamada M, et al
. New perspectives on dry eye definition and diagnosis: A consensus report by the Asia Dry Eye Society. Ocul Surf 2017;15:65-76.
Friedman NJ. Impact of dry eye disease and treatment on quality of life. Curr Opin Ophthalmol 2010;21:310-6.
Abusharha AA, Pearce EI. The effect of low humidity on the human tear film. Cornea 2013;32:429-34.
Sahai A, Malik P. Dry eye: Prevalence and attributable risk factors in a hospital-based population. Indian J Ophthalmol 2005;53:87-91.
] [Full text]
Torricelli AA, Novaes P, Matsuda M, Braga A, Saldiva PH, Alves MR, et al
. Correlation between signs and symptoms of ocular surface dysfunction and tear osmolarity with ambient levels of air pollution in a large metropolitan area. Cornea 2013;32:e11-5.
Hwang SH, Choi YH, Paik HJ, Wee WR, Kim MK, Kim DH. Potential importance of ozone in the association between outdoor air pollution and dry eye disease in South Korea. JAMA Ophthalmol 2016;134:503-10.
Kumar N, Feuer W, Lanza NL, Galor A. Seasonal variation in dry eye. Ophthalmology 2015;122:1727-9.
Abusharha AA, Pearce EI, Fagehi R. Effect of ambient temperature on the human tear film. Eye Contact Lens 2016;42:308-12.
Zhong JY, Lee YC, Hsieh CJ, Tseng CC, Yiin LM. Association between dry eye disease, air pollution and weather changes in Taiwan. Int J Environ Res Public Health 2018;15:2269.
Bartlett JD, Keith MS, Sudharshan L, Snedecor SJ. Associations between signs and symptoms of dry eye disease: A systematic review. Clin Ophthalmol 2015;9:1719-30.
Schiffman RM, Christianson MD, Jacobsen G, Hirsch JD, Reis BL. Reliability and validity of the ocular surface disease index. Arch Ophthalmol 2000;118:615-21.
Blackie CA, Solomon JD, Scaffidi RC, Greiner JV, Lemp MA, Korb DR. The relationship between dry eye symptoms and lipid layer thickness. Cornea 2009;28:789-94.
Mandell JT, Idarraga M, Kumar N, Galor A. Impact of air pollution and weather on dry eye. J Clin Med 2020;9:3740.
Chuang MT, Lee CT, Hsu HC. Quantifying PM2.5
from long-range transport and local pollution in Taiwan during winter monsoon: An efficient estimation method. J Environ Manage 2018;227:10-22.
Chang CJ, Yang HH, Chang CA, Tsai HY. Relationship between air pollution and outpatient visits for nonspecific conjunctivitis. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 2012;53:429-33.
Weng HY, Ho WT, Chiu CY, Tsai TY, Chang SW. Characteristics of tear film lipid layer in young dry eye patients. J Formos Med Assoc 2021;120:1478-1484.
Su TY, Chang SW. Normalized ocular surface temperature models for tear film characteristics and dry eye disease evaluation. Ocul Surf 2021;19:74-82.
Griffith SM, Huang WS, Lin CC, Chen YC, Chang KE, Lin TH, et al
. Long-range air pollution transport in East Asia during the first week of the COVID-19 lockdown in China. Sci Total Environ 2020;741:140214.
Tsai CW, Hsiao YR, Lin ML, Hsu Y. Development of a noise-assisted multivariate empirical mode decomposition framework for characterizing PM 2.5 air pollution in Taiwan and its relation to hydro-meteorological factors. Environ Int 2020;139:105669.
Butovich IA, Arciniega JC, Wojtowicz JC. Meibomian lipid films and the impact of temperature. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 2010;51:5508-18.
Belmonte C, Nichols JJ, Cox SM, Brock JA, Begley CG, Bereiter DA, et al
. TFOS DEWS II pain and sensation report. Ocul Surf 2017;15:404-37.
Hirata H, Meng ID. Cold-sensitive corneal afferents respond to a variety of ocular stimuli central to tear production: Implications for dry eye disease. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 2010;51:3969-76.
Kovács I, Luna C, Quirce S, Mizerska K, Callejo G, Riestra A, et al
. Abnormal activity of corneal cold thermoreceptors underlies the unpleasant sensations in dry eye disease. Pain 2016;157:399-417.
Kuo YK, Lin IC, Chien LN, Lin TY, How YT, Chen KH, et al
. Dry eye disease: A review of epidemiology in Taiwan, and its clinical treatment and merits. J Clin Med 2019;8:1227.
Uchino M, Nishiwaki Y, Michikawa T, Shirakawa K, Kuwahara E, Yamada M, et al
. Prevalence and risk factors of dry eye disease in Japan: Koumi study. Ophthalmology 2011;118:2361-7.
Um SB, Kim NH, Lee HK, Song JS, Kim HC. Spatial epidemiology of dry eye disease: Findings from South Korea. Int J Health Geogr 2014;13:31.
Zhang Y, Chen H, Wu X. Prevalence and risk factors associated with dry eye syndrome among senior high school students in a county of Shandong Province, China. Ophthalmic Epidemiol 2012;19:226-30.
[Figure 1], [Figure 2]
[Table 1], [Table 2], [Table 3], [Table 4], [Table 5], [Table 6]